Short answer: Open an incognito window, search 10 to 15 real customer questions from your own town, and look at the "AI Overview" panel above the blue links. Expand its source cards. If your website is one of them, Google is recommending you. If not, you are not cited yet. The test is free and takes about 15 minutes.
That is the whole method. Everything below is how to run it properly, why signing out matters, and what to do with the answer once you have it. You do not need a tool, a login, or a marketer to do this. You need the same window a stranger would use to find you.
A bakery owner in Leeds does not need a subscription to learn whether Google's robot is sending customers her way. She needs 15 minutes and one clean browser window. This is the calm version of what an SEO agency would charge you for.
Know what an AI Overview actually looks like
Before you go looking for your site, know what you are looking at. An AI Overview is the boxed answer that sits above the normal blue links, with a small "AI Overview" label at the top. Google writes a few sentences answering the question, then shows a set of clickable source cards, usually down the right side or just below the text, naming the pages it pulled the answer from.
Those source cards are the prize. Each one is a website Google decided was worth citing. An AI Overview does not quote a single page. Semrush studied 200,000 AI Overviews and found an average of 11 links inside one Overview, with some outliers carrying more than 106 links. That matters for you: there is not one slot to win, there are roughly a dozen. Room exists for the plumber, the bakery, and the accountant on the same result.
So your test is simple. When the AI Overview appears, you are asking one question. Is my website in those cards, or not?
Sign out and open an incognito window first
Here is the mistake almost everyone makes. They Google their own business while signed in, see themselves near the top, and relax. That result is a lie built specially for you.
Google personalizes what you see. It knows your location, your search history, and the sites you visit often, including your own. Signed in, it shows you a flattering version of yourself that no customer will ever see. A practitioner named Matt Pru, writing up the manual method for confirming AI Overview presence, put it plainly: "Personalization affects search results. Test in a clean environment. Use Incognito Mode."
So do that. Open a new incognito or private window (Ctrl+Shift+N on Chrome, Cmd+Shift+N on a Mac). Do not sign in. This strips out your history and shows you close to what a first-time visitor gets. It is the single step that separates a real test from a comforting one. If you want the fuller picture of how Google decides who to cite, our guide to how Google AI Overviews work walks through the mechanics.
Write down 10 to 15 real customer questions
Now write the questions. Not your business name. The problems you solve.
The trap is searching "Sweet Ivy Bakery" and feeling good when your own site shows up. Of course it does. Nobody who already knows your name is the customer you are trying to reach through AI Overviews. The customer you want has a problem and no idea you exist yet. She types "best gluten-free birthday cake near me" or "where to order a vegan wedding cake in Leeds."
Sit down and write 10 to 15 of those. Think like the stranger, not the owner. A plumber would list "why is my radiator cold at the bottom," "emergency boiler repair near me," "how much to fix a leaking tap." A salon would list "balayage for dark hair near me," "best place for a keratin treatment." Cover the questions that come before someone knows who you are, because that is exactly the moment an AI Overview does its work.
One question per line. Keep the list. You will reuse it every time you re-test.
Run each search from your own town and read the source cards
Take your list into the incognito window and search each question, one at a time. Because you are signed out, Google may ask for or guess your location. Make sure it reflects your actual service area, not a default city, since a "near me" search only makes sense from the right town.
For each search, do two things. First, check whether an AI Overview even appears. It will not always. Then, if it does, expand the source cards and read the domains. You are hunting for your own website address in that list. Write down the result next to each question: Overview shown or not, and cited or not.
Do not expect a clean pattern. AI Overviews are volatile. Semrush's study of more than 10 million keywords found they appeared for 6.49% of queries in January 2025, climbed to nearly 25% by July, then settled at 15.69% by November 2025. The same search can carry an Overview one month and drop it the next. This is not a glitch in your test. It is the nature of the thing you are measuring, which is why you write down what you see instead of trusting a single glance.
This is honest work, and it is slower than a dashboard. Doing this check across a range of owner-run businesses, the pattern that shows up again and again is that the sites getting cited are the ones with a plain page that directly answers the exact question, while the sites that never appear usually have a services page that lists what they do but never answers what a customer asked. The test does not just tell you if you are in. It quietly shows you why.
Check what Search Console can (and cannot) tell you
You may be wondering why you cannot just open Google Search Console and read this off a chart. Here is the precise answer, because a lot of advice online gets it wrong.
By default, Search Console does not break out AI Overview visibility at all. Google states that this data "is included in the overall performance report." Your AI Overview clicks and impressions are folded into your normal totals, with no separate line for them.
On June 3, 2026, Google did launch a separate Generative AI performance report, covering AI Overviews and AI Mode. Two things about it matter. It is still rolling out to only a subset of sites, so you may not have it yet. And it is impressions only. It shows impressions, pages, countries, devices, and dates. It does not show clicks, click-through rate, position, or the queries behind them. Google's own June 2026 help documentation confirms the report is impression-based.
Read that carefully, because it is the whole reason this article exists. An impression count tells you an AI feature appeared on a search where your site was involved. It does not tell you that you were named in the AI Overview. It cannot confirm you were cited. Only looking at the source cards with your own eyes can do that. Search Console is useful for trends over time once you have the report, but for the yes-or-no question of "did Google cite me," the manual incognito search is still the method that works. For the wider picture of tracking what AI search sends you, see our guide to measuring AI traffic in your analytics.
Re-run the test every 30 to 60 days
Do this test once and you have a snapshot. Do it every 30 to 60 days and you have a picture.
The reason is the volatility already covered: the same query gains and loses its Overview month to month, and the source cards inside it shift too. A page you were cited in during March can quietly drop out by May with nothing changed on your end. This is not a reason to panic. It is a reason to keep a simple log. Same question list, same incognito window, every month or two, and note what moved.
This is common now, not a fringe worry. As of Google's May 2025 update, AI Overviews were available in over 200 countries and territories and more than 40 languages. Wherever your customers search, an Overview can show for them. Checking twice a year is not obsessive. It is the same as glancing at your reviews.
What to do if you are never cited
If you run all 15 searches and your site never appears, take a breath. That is a fixable content problem, not a verdict on your business.
Being absent from AI Overviews usually means one thing: no page on your site answers the question in the clear, direct shape these systems like to quote. The fix is to build those pages, one plain answer per real customer question, the same questions you just wrote down. Our playbook for getting your business into Google AI Overviews is the next step, and it uses the exact list you already made. Google is not the only AI worth checking, either. It is worth running the same kind of test on other assistants, which our guide to checking whether ChatGPT recommends your business covers.
The test told you where you stand. The content work is how you change it.
Frequently asked questions
Do I really need to use incognito mode to check this?
Yes, and it is the step people skip. Signed in, Google personalizes results using your location and history, so it shows you a flattering version that includes your own site. An incognito window strips that away and shows you roughly what a new customer sees, which is the only result that tells you the truth.
Why does an AI Overview show for a search one week and not the next?
Because AI Overviews are genuinely volatile. Semrush's study of over 10 million keywords found they went from 6.49% of queries in January 2025 to nearly 25% in July, then back to 15.69% by November. Google turns them on and off for the same query as it tests things, so a month-to-month re-test is normal, not paranoia.
Can Google Search Console just tell me if I appear in AI Overviews?
Not directly. By default this data is folded into your overall performance report with no separate line. Google's June 2026 Generative AI report is rolling out to some sites and shows impressions only, no clicks and no queries, and it does not confirm you were cited. A manual search is still how you verify.
How many questions should I actually test?
Aim for 10 to 15 real customer questions, phrased the way a stranger would type them, not your business name. That range is wide enough to spot a pattern without turning the check into an afternoon. Keep the same list and reuse it every time so your results stay comparable.
If your search shows your site sitting in those source cards, Google's robot is already doing your selling for you. If it does not, you now know exactly which questions to answer, in the customer's own words, on your own pages. That is the quiet advantage of the 15-minute test: it hands you a to-do list instead of a worry. Fonzy exists to run that check and build those answer-shaped pages for you on autopilot, so you can go back to running the bakery.
Sources
- Semrush AI Overviews Study: what 10M+ keywords show about volatility (6.49% to 25% to 15.69% across 2025)
- Semrush study of 200,000 AI Overviews: an average of 11 source links per Overview
- Google Search Central: the June 2026 Generative AI performance report is impressions-only and rolling out to a subset of sites
- Google (The Keyword): AI Overviews available in 200+ countries and 40+ languages as of May 2025
- Stackmatix: manual incognito method for confirming AI Overview presence


Ready to grow?

